Jerry Angelo's Worst Draft Picks
by Roy Taylor © 2012
10. Jarron Gilbert and Juaquin Iglesias-Round
3 2009: In the 2009 draft it was critical for the Bears to hit on their picks,
as they did not have a first-rounder due to the trade for Jay Cutler. Chicago's
first pick that year was in the second round, 49th overall. Jerry Angelo and
his staff decided to trade down rather than use the selection, netting
Seattle's third and fourth-round picks in return. With the extra picks the
Bears selected Iglesias, wide receiver from Oklahoma in the third, and
cornerback D.J. Moore from Vanderbilt. Moore has ended up to this point being a
solid, playmaking nickel back unsuited to be a starting corner. But available
in the second round were center Max Unger and tackle Sebastian Vollmer, solid
players in the NFL at what are still need positions for the Bears. With their
own third-round pick, the Bears selected defensive tackle Jarron Gilbert from
San Jose State. Gilbert was a relative unknown who became a draft sensation
when the You Tube video of him jumping out of a pool from a crouch
[http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rXDSPbZ_OUw]. Too bad Gilbert's pool-jumping
skills never translated to the NFL; he was active for four games as a Bear and
cut the following season. Iglesias was active for only one game as a Bear, and
Chicago let the Minnesota Vikings sign him off their practice squad in 2010.
Two third-round picks, four games active, nothing in return.
9. Roosevelt Williams-CB-Tuskegee-Round 3
2002: Angelo started his penchant for trading down in the first draft he led as
a general manager. In 2002, instead of using the 63rd overall pick the Bears
traded down nine spots in exchange for the Dallas Cowboy's third-round pick and
a swap of fourth-rounders. With the extra pick in the third, the Bears selected
Williams. The cornerback was from a small school, but was a draft-climber that
was considered a potential small school sleeper. But it didn't happen. When the
2002 Bears' season fell apart en route to their 4-12 finish, Williams earned
playing time. He was burned several times while in the lineup, but did make a
game-saving tackle in a late season victory over the New York Jets. He did not
make the 2003 Bears roster. Remarkably, Williams did end up starting three
games for the Cleveland Browns in 2003, his last in the NFL.
8. Dan LeFevour-QB-Central Michigan-Round 6
2010: It's hard to call any sixth-round draft pick a mistake, since the vast
majority of these players aren't expected to go onto great NFL success. And Dan
LeFevour was a record-setting college quarterback. But there are several
reasons for this. Late in the 2010 season it was revealed that during that
year's draft, Angelo's staff had called Buffalo running back James Starks and
told him he would be Chicago's sixth-round pick, 181st overall. The drafting of
Starks would have been a sly move, as he had spent his senior college season
out of football with an injury. But after they had called Starks, the Bears
changed their mind, picking LeFevour instead. The Bears ended up waiving
LeFevour in the final preseason cutdown with hopes of signing him to their
practice squad, but the Cincinnati Bengals pounced, adding him to their active
roster. Starks was nabbed by the hated Green Bay Packers with the 193rd overall
pick of the draft, and began to earn significant playing time in 2010, even
leading the Packers in rushing and scoring a touchdown against the Bears in the
NFC Championship game the Bears lost at home. Granted, Starks may not be a
long-term starting running back in the NFL. But the Bears got nothing out of
LeFevour. And considering the wasted gambles the Bears have made on Matt
Forte's backup in 2010 and 2011 (Chester Taylor and Marion Barber III), in
retrospect Starks should have remained Chicago's pick after that fateful phone
call. Former Bear personnel director Greg Gabriel stated it was his most
embarassing moment in scouting.
7. Garrett Wolfe-RB-Northern Illinois-Round 3
2007: Angelo again traded down in the ill-fated 2007 NFL draft, a year that
failed to produce a single selection that is still with the team as of 2012.
For the Bears' 37th overall selection (obtained in a swap of second-round picks
with the New York Jets for RB Thomas Jones), the Bears obtained from San Diego
their second, third and fifth-round picks in 2007 as well as their
third-rounder in 2008. With the Chargers' third-round pick the Bears chose
Wolfe. The pick was a shock to most, as the diminutive runner was predicted by
most draftniks to go anywhere from the sixth round to being an undrafted free
agent. Yet Angelo made the pick in a place where winning teams need to find
starters. Angelo would go on to say that his organization felt so strongly
about Wolfe that in the end it didn't matter where he was selected, as long as
the Bears got him. In retrospect, players Angelo might have selected rather
than Wolfe included starting NFL tackles Doug Free and Jermon Bushrod, safety
Dashon Goldson, or new Bears running back Michael Bush. Wolfe was tried as a
gadget on offense by the Bears mostly in his rookie season, without much
success. Wolfe did end up being a solid special teamer, but in his four years
with the Bears only rushed 72 times for 282 yards (3.9 yard average) and a
single touchdown.
6. Chris Williams-T-Vanderbilt-Round 1 2008:
In fairness, entering 2012 Williams is still a starter for the Bears, unlike
many of Jerry Angelo's top draft picks. He has not been a complete bust, but
with the 14th overall selection in a draft, general managers are held
accountable for strong results. The Bears needed a left tackle in this draft
badly following a bad drop in the line's production in 2007. Right tackle Fred
Miller in particular had regressed. And in the '08 draft there was quality and
quantity at the position. In retrospect, being that he was in the market for a
tackle, Angelo might have done whatever it took to trade up two spots for
perennial All-Pro tackle Ryan Clady instead of letting the Denver Broncos take
him. (Although this most certainly would have required the Bears second-round
pick and more, so no drafting Matt Forte.) As far as projected left tackles
went, in terms of skills, Williams was the next best available prospect after
Clady and top overall pick Jake Long. Pittsburgh's Jeff Otah was thought to be
a better prospect, but completely projected on the right side of the line.
Virgina's Branden Albert was another top prospect who projected on the left
side or as a guard. Problem was, it was later revealed that Williams was off
many teams' draft boards altogether due to concerns with recurring back
injuries. Angelo made Williams the pick, and on the first day of training camp
Williams injured his back. This put him down for most of his rookie season,
forcing veteran John Tait to move to the right side and journeyman John St.
Clair to man the left side throughout the season. Williams would start through
the 2009 season and early in 2010 at left tackle, before being moved to guard.
Midway through the 2011 season Williams injured his hand and was lost for the
year. The jury is still out on Williams, who is set to become a free agent
following the 2012 season. Again when GM's are expected to score with players
in the top half of the first round, Angelo did in our opinion strike out here.
Had the Bears drafted for the best overall player, they may have been better
off selecting Albert.
5. Michael Okwo-LB-Stanford-Round 3 2007:
Another collosal bust from the 2007 draft. Okwo was selected with the Bears'
own third-round draft pick that year. The team was in the thick of Lance
Briggs' (first) contract dispute, and Angelo projected Okwo to have a similar
skillset to Briggs. Okwo was placed on injured reserve prior to his rookie
season, then released before the 2008 campaign. Nothing more to say about the
player other than Angelo threw away a high draft pick for nothing in the end.
4. Mark Bradley-WR-Oklahoma-Round 2 2005:
Bradley was not listed anywhere in the 2005 version of Lindy's NFL Draft guide,
thus I reacted to the pick with wonderment. He was tall and fast, and also had
red flags flapping in the wind around him due to knee injuries. Bradley looked
like he would be a find in the first half of his rookie season, then he tore
his ACL as he had done previously in college. He then continued as only a role
player in 2006 and 2007. He was cut shortly into the 2008 season. Bradley was
selected extremely high-with the seventh pick in the second round. Players that
the Bears could have selected in that spot included Pro Bowlers Michael Roos
(OT), Nick Collins (S), or Vincent Jackson (WR). Bradley finished his Bears
career with 583 receiving yards on 34 catches and four touchdowns.
3. Dan Bazuin-DE-Central Michigan-Round 2
2007: One of Angelo's collosal busts. Angelo thought the small-school end would
be a sleeper. Not much here to write about a player that never suited up for a
game and was cut following one year on injured reserve. In fairness to Bazuin
and Angelo, a knee injury during the preseason followed by a second surgery
didn't help the situation. But even after coming back healthy, Bazuin failed to
catch on elsewhere in the NFL. Whether this was due to lack of overall talent
or directly due to the injury, we will never know.
2. Michael Haynes-DE-Penn State-Round 1 2003:
The biggest busts are reserved for the failed first-round picks. Haynes was
selected with the 14th overall pick, their top pick in the draft that year,
after leading the Big Ten conference in sacks the previous year. The Bears
could have stayed with the 13th pick and taken a solid player in defensive end
Ty Warren, but traded down one spot with the New England Patriots. At that spot
the Bears might have chosen safety Troy Polamalu, center Jeff Faine, guard Eric
Steinbeck or cornerback Nnamdi Asomugha, but they didn't. Haynes only started
four games for the Bears, registered 5.5 sacks, and was cut after three
seasons.
1. Cedric Benson-RB-Texas-Round 1 2005: With
the fourth overall pick in the 2005 draft, the Bears selected Cedric Benson. My
personal favorite pre-draft line about Benson was that he was built like
(former Saint and Dolphin) Ricky Williams, but wasn't as good and had more
potential for problems. And the pundits were right. Benson was in full-fledged
bawling mode when he went to the podium as the fourth-overall pick, and would
later reveal that they weren't tears of happiness. No, Benson was crying
because his agent had advised the Bears not to draft him because the Bears
weren't prepared to meet Benson's contract demands. Thus Benson knew he would
be a holdout from the moment he was drafted. And hold out he did, not arriving
with the Bears until 36 days after the other players reported, after the entire
preseason was over. And the players did not take kindly to the new arrival.
Benson looked solid in spot duty in 2005 before being injured and missing
significant playing time, then again looked good in a supporting role to
starter Thomas Jones in the 2006 Super Bowl season. Prior to 2007 Angelo traded
Thomas Jones to pave the way full time for Benson, and Benson again missed much
of the season with an injury. In his sole season as the starter Benson rushed
for 647 yards and four touchdowns. Following an arrest prior to the 2008
season, the Bears cut ties with their highest draft pick since they had
selected Dan Hampton in 1979. Players available in the draft when Benson was
selected included DeMarcus Ware, Carlos Rogers, Antrel Rolle, Jammal Brown,
Aaron Rodgers and Roddy White.
|