Jerry Angelo's Worst Acquisitions
by Roy Taylor © 2012
10. Brandon Meriweather-S-Free Agent 2011: I
lauded this pickup when it happened. Meriweather was the New England Patriots'
first-round draft pick in the 2007 draft and a former Pro Bowler. But
Meriweather was also known to be undisciplined and reckless on and off the
field. Angelo snatched up Meriweather and gave him a lucrative one-year
contract as soon as the Patriots released him in the final preseason cutdowns.
In his four games as a starter for the Bears, Meriweather seemed more
interested in teeing off for big (and frequently illegal) hits on opponents
rather than playing in the defensive scheme. Despite Chicago's need for talent
at the position, Meriweather quickly played his way onto the bench for the
remainder of the 2011 season. He was supplanted in the starting lineup by
rookie Chris Conte.
9. Chester Taylor-RB-Free Agent 2010: Taylor
was second on the list of three successive failed players at the backup running
back position. Because former Lion Kevin Jones couldn't stay healthy, and
starter Matt Forte was coming off a somewhat disappointing sophomore season,
the Bears threw $7 million guaranteed at Taylor when he became a free agent.
Despite being 29 years old, it was thought that Taylor's legs were fresh as he
had only been a starter in the league for one season (2006). He had spent the
majority of his career backing up Jamal Lewis in Baltimore and Adrian Peterson
in Minnesota. For the $7 million the Bears paid Taylor for one season, they
received 267 yards rushing with a 2.4 yard average per carry and three
touchdowns.
8. Brandon Manumaleuna-TE-Free Agent 2010:
The boneheaded signings of Chester Taylor and Manumaleuna in 2010 went
hand-in-hand. Manumaleuna ostensibly was demanded by offensive coordinator Mike
Martz when he came to town, the tight end having been drafted by Martz in St.
Louis. Manumaleuna was nothing more than a third offensive tackle to block for
Martz' frequent seven-step drop pass plays. But he didn't even do that well, as
I distinctly remember him being blown by on several critical sacks of Jay
Cutler in 2010. Like Taylor, Manumaleuna was guaranteed an enormous amount for
his one season in Chicago: $6.1 million. And the return was virtually nothing.
7. Roy Williams-WR-Free Agent 2011: At least
the Bears didn't do what Dallas did when they gave up first and third-round
draft picks for the enigmatic receiver. Williams had enjoyed success in Detroit
under Mike Martz, making the Pro Bowl in the 2006 season. He was a flop in
Dallas, and when the Cowboys released him prior to the 2011 season, Angelo
signed the veteran to a "prove it" deal for one season and over $2 million in
salary. What Williams proved is that he's probably done in football. While his
stats were OK given the undewhelming history with Bears receivers, he
short-armed and dropped too many passes as has become his trademark.
6. Kordell Stewart-QB-Free Agent 2003:
Probably anticipating that he would be drafting a quarterback, and with the
release of veteran starter Jim Miller, Angelo was in the market for the
standard veteran quarterback to guide and tutor the rookie. So free agent
Kordell Stewart was signed. Stewart had a very up-and-down career with the
Steelers. Drafted in the second-round in 1995, used as the original "Slash" at
wide receiver and running back, Stewart became Pittsburgh's starting
quarterback in 1997. He had played himself out of a job by 2000, but was
starting again and actually made the Pro Bowl in 2001. But in 2002 he lost his
job again due to poor play and was released. Angelo figured Stewart would
provide a unique weapon for offensive coordinator John Shoop, to be used in
such plays that turned out to be quarterback draws after a fake handoff that
drew linebackers into the hole. Stewart started seven games in his one year
with the Bears. He was intially benched due to poor play for the aged Chris
Chandler, then reassumed the starting position after Chandler was injured. Then
he yielded to rookie Rex Grossman when the Bears were out of the playoff race.
He threw seven touchdown passes, 12 interceptions and only completed 50% of his
passes.
5. Frank Omiyale-OL-Free Agent 2009: Angelo
steadfastly refused to build the offensive line through the draft during his
tenure. Granted, his very first pick was an offensive lineman (Marc Colombo in
2002). But aside from 2008 first-round pick Chris Williams, Angelo only
selected linemen in the mid to late rounds of the draft. At the start of free
agency in 2009, Angelo's first move was to sign Omiyale to a four-year, $14
million contract as a starting offensive lineman. Omiyale had done a decent job
as a fill-in at right tackle in Carolina, and Angelo planned to make him a
starting guard. Omilyale flopped in the role in 2009. What is still surprising
is that when he was moved to the critical left tackle position in 2010, Omiyale
played admirably, if not solidly. But in 2011 he was forced to substitute at
right tackle, and played like a turnstile. He was released following the 2011
season. Omiyale might have been a mere blip in the Jerry Angelo story, but
counting on this gamble to return solid offensive line play did not pan out.
4. Jonathan Quinn-QB-Free Agent 2004: Rex
Grossman had showed promise at the end of the 2003 season to be the Bears'
quarterback of the future. His injury history to that point was clean, so the
position of backup quarterback wasn't thought to of urgent focus. When Angelo
signed Quinn, Kansas City's backup quarterback, the reason was more to tutor
Grossman on new offensive coordinator Terry Shea's offense than for the actual
need to step in and play the majority of the season. And Quinn had shown
promise when he took the field for his former team, the Jacksonville Jaguars.
Then fate intervened when Grossman tore his ACL in the third week of the
season, thrusting Quinn into the starting role. He only kept the job for three
weeks before being pulled for rookie fifth-round draft pick Craig Krenzel, and
was cut as a failure following the season. Quinn threw for one touchdown and
three interceptions with a 52% completion percentage. Like any decision that
turns out to be bad in the game of football, any signing is a crapshoot until a
player proves himself. This crapshoot did not work out.
3. Gaines Adams-DE-Trade 2009: The fact that
Adams died tragically of a heart condition following the 2009 season is not a
consideration here. This was still an awful move when Angelo sent Tampa Bay a
second-round draft pick in 2010 for Adams, who had underwhelmed on the field
despite being the fourth overall pick in the 2007 draft. In 10 games with the
Bears in 2009, Adams registered only seven tackles, one pass defensed and one
forced fumble. Many in the league had already felt that Tampa fleeced the Bears
in the trade, even before Adams died tragically. Adams' death paved the way for
the Bears to pursue Julius Peppers hard in 2010 free agency.
2. Adam Archuleta-S-Trade 2007: Archuleta was
a first-round draft pick by Lovie Smith during his first year as defensive
coordinator in St. Louis. He was an All-Rookie selection in 2001, and a solid
safety for the Rams through the 2005 season. In one of their usual free agent
signing binges, in 2006 the Washington Redskins signed Archuleta to a six-year,
$30 million contract. In just one season with the Redskins, he started only
seven games and had fallen out of favor with his new team. Smith was clearly
enamored with Archuleta and as soon as word spread that he might be available
in a trade with Washington, the Bears dealt a sixth-round pick for him. They
also guaranteed him $5.1 million in salary for 2007. Archuleta started 10 games
at safety for the Bears but was benched, then cut, when he proved he could no
longer cover or wrap up tackles. After the acquisition of Archuleta, the Bears
traded starting safety Chris Harris to the Carolina Panthers. When incumbent
safety Mike Brown was lost for the season in the opener, it put even more
pressure on Archuleta to perform, which he did not.
1. Todd Collins-QB-Free Agent 2010: In the
grand scheme of his ten seasons leading the Chicago Bears, perhaps listing a
one-season backup quarterback as Jerry Angelo's worst personnel acquisition is
not fair or legitimate. Collins only played in two regular season games and one
playoff game, and word has it that the signing was demanded by offensive
coordinator Mike Martz. Perhaps it is fairer to say that neglect of the backup
quarterback position is the problem more than the signing of Collins, to be
exact. But the fact is the Bears' failure to win one more game to advance to
Super Bowl 45 was a direct result of not having a competent backup to replace
Jay Cutler in case of injury, which happened in the 2010 NFC Championship Game
at home against bitter rival Green Bay. Collins was absymal in his every
appearance in 2010, including the majority of the third quarter of that
critical game.
|